Shadowheart's Daughter of Darkness Quest Guide (Baldur's Gate 3): Shar or Selûne, Nightsong and Her Parents
How to complete Daughter of Darkness: the Gauntlet of Shar, the Nightsong choice and its DC checks, Viconia in the House of Grief and how to save Shadowheart's parents.
Art: Larian StudiosSpoiler warning: this guide covers Shadowheart's full story, including both paths and the ending of her Act 3 quest.
Daughter of Darkness is Shadowheart's companion quest. It starts automatically when she joins your party and runs through all three acts. The big decision comes at the end of Act 2 in the Gauntlet of Shar: kill the Nightsong and Shadowheart stays with Shar, or spare it and she turns toward Selûne. The safest way to spare it is to not pick the first persuasion line in that scene. Respect her decision and wait for the easier check that comes after it.
| At a glance | |
|---|---|
| Starts | When Shadowheart joins (Nautiloid pod, Ravaged Beach or later in Act 1) |
| Key items | Spear of Night (Silent Library), all four Umbral Gems |
| Must-have | Shadowheart in the active party when you descend into the Shadowfell |
| Big choice | Kill or spare the Nightsong (Act 2) |
| Act 3 | House of Grief, Viconia DeVir, Shadowheart's parents |
| Rewards | Shar's Spear of Evening, or Moonlight Glaive + Selûne's Spear of Night |
Before Act 2: build up to the Nightsong
Shadowheart can decide to spare the Nightsong on her own, without any dice roll, if you have earned enough of her trust. This hidden score is built from small conversations in Acts 1 and 2:
- Ask about her wound and about the wolf memory she has after you kill wolves near her.
- Talk her into eating the Noblestalk mushroom in the Underdark (a DC 12 Persuasion or Intimidation check).
- Give her a Night Orchid; it also unlocks the achievement To Bloom in Darkest Night.
- Agree to help her with the trials in the Gauntlet of Shar.
Combine most of these with high approval and the Nightsong scene becomes much easier. You can still finish the quest without them.
Step by step
- Recruit Shadowheart and keep her approval up. High approval matters for the Nightsong and her parents later.
- Enter the Gauntlet of Shar in Act 2 (below the Shadow-Cursed Lands). Complete the trials to collect the four Umbral Gems, and take the Spear of Night from the Silent Library. The Spear is what Shar wants Shadowheart to use.
- Bring Shadowheart into the Shadowfell. The final chamber opens with the gems. Shadowheart must be in your active party when you jump into the pool, or she leaves for good.
- Stop Balthazar. The necromancer is waiting to take the Nightsong. If you let him, Shadowheart leaves when you exit. Refuse and fight him. Keep area spells away from the Nightsong while you fight.
- Make the Nightsong choice (see below). This is effectively the end of Act 2, so finish any Act 1 or 2 business first.
- Defeat Ketheric Thorm. If you spared the Nightsong, talk to Aylin at camp after the battle.
- Act 3: find the Sharran lookout at the bridge to the city (Wyrm's Crossing, near Rivington). It points you to the House of Grief in the northwest of the Lower City.
- Trigger the Mother Superior. Have Shadowheart sit on the granite bench inside the House of Grief. The Mother Superior is Viconia DeVir.
- Open the inner sanctum. Take the Black Diamond from the altar and use the Silver Key. Shadowheart's parents are chained inside, and her real name is revealed.
The Nightsong: kill or spare
Kill her (Shar path). Shadowheart becomes a Dark Justiciar and gets Shar's Spear of Evening, a legendary spear with Shar's Darkness and blindness immunity. The cost is heavy: without the Nightsong's protection, Isobel dies and the Last Light Inn falls. Jaheira and Dammon die, and Art Cullagh can die too, which can cost you Halsin.
Spare her (Selûne path). Two persuasion moments come up:
- The first line ("Your life is what you make it…") is a DC 30 check. Failing and pushing further turns her hostile. Skip it.
- Respect her choice instead. A second check at DC 21 follows. Stack Guidance, Enhance Ability (Eagle's Splendour) or Bardic Inspiration on it.
If it works, Shadowheart throws the spear into the void. Aylin (the Nightsong) gives her the Moonlight Glaive, and an angel helps you fight Ketheric. After Thorm falls, talk to Aylin at camp for Selûne's Spear of Night, a legendary +3 spear with Moonbeam, Moonmote, advantage on Wisdom saves and Perception checks, and 12 m darkvision.
Act 3 choices
Viconia. Defend Shadowheart and you fight Viconia and over a dozen cultists. Killing her gives Minsc approval and loot, including Viconia's Walking Fortress shield. Surrendering Shadowheart to her instead makes Viconia's followers join you for the final battle.
Her parents. In the Chamber of Loss, Shadowheart decides what to do with them:
| Choice | Outcome |
|---|---|
| End their suffering | They turn into moonmotes; Shadowheart is free of Shar |
| Stay silent / "your choice" | They die |
| Save them | Needs a DC 20 Religion or Persuasion check (or enough trust); they recover at your camp |
| Shar path, she kills them | She takes over the Sharran church |
Common mistakes
- Picking the first persuasion line at the Nightsong. It is the hard DC 30 check.
- Entering the Shadowfell without Shadowheart, or letting Balthazar take the Nightsong.
- Killing the Nightsong without realizing it dooms Isobel, Jaheira and the Last Light Inn.
- Forgetting to talk to Aylin at camp, so Selûne's Spear of Night never drops.
- Rushing past the small Act 1 conversations that make the Nightsong scene easier.
FAQ
Can I do the Selûne path if I don't romance her? Yes. Romance isn't required. Approval and the conversations above make it easier.
Is it worth killing the Nightsong? Only if you want Shadowheart's Shar story. You lose several important characters at Last Light, and Shar's spear is no stronger than Selûne's.
Sources
This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.