How to Get the Lancaster Repeater for Free in Red Dead Redemption 2

Discover the Rhodes gunsmith's basement, confront the owner, and take the Lancaster Repeater from the weapon case in Story Mode.

Lancaster RepeaterArt: Rockstar Games

You can get a free Lancaster Repeater in Red Dead Redemption 2 Story Mode by investigating the captive in the basement window at the Rhodes gunsmith. Speak to him outside, enter the shop, aim at the owner, and select the basement robbery option. Follow the gunsmith downstairs and open the weapon case for the repeater.

@img

This is a Story Mode discovery, not a way to obtain a free Lancaster in Red Dead Online. Chapter 2 is a convenient time to do it, before later story restrictions temporarily prevent Arthur from using weapons around Rhodes.

1. Find the basement window

Ride to Rhodes and locate the gunsmith on the town map. Before entering the front door, walk around the right side of the building as viewed from the street.

Look near ground level for the small barred basement window. Approach and speak to the young man inside. Finish the conversation so Arthur recognizes the suspicious situation.

Simply standing near the shop or hearing something unusual is not enough to reliably expose the correct confrontation option. Make sure you actually interact with the captive before going inside.

If you arrive at night or the shop is unavailable, return when the owner is conducting business. Avoid beginning with a random robbery outside the building; you need the owner to lead you into the basement.

2. Confront the gunsmith inside

Enter the store and aim a weapon at the gunsmith. Read the interaction options and choose the one concerning the basement, rather than only demanding the cash register's money.

Keep the owner alive and let the conversation proceed. Killing him immediately can interrupt the intended sequence and is unnecessary for obtaining the weapon.

Once he agrees to show you downstairs, follow him through the back access. Do not keep firing or attacking while he is opening the route. The important action is getting the basement opened, not escalating the robbery into a town-wide shootout.

If you only see an ordinary robbery prompt, put away the weapon when safe and check whether you completed the outside window conversation. If the current story forbids weapon use in Rhodes, return after that restriction is lifted.

3. Inspect the basement and free the captive

Follow the scene downstairs. The imprisoned man is chained, and you can free him by carefully shooting the chain.

Use a precise shot and make sure your aim is on the metal link rather than his body. Take a moment to position yourself with a clear view; rushing a shot in the small room is an easy way to harm the person you came to help.

Listen to the dialogue if you want the full context of the encounter. You do not need to kill the gunsmith to receive the Lancaster, and doing so adds consequences unrelated to the weapon pickup.

The rescue and the rifle are separate interactions in the same room. Freeing the captive does not automatically place the repeater in Arthur's weapon inventory.

4. Open the weapon case

Search the basement for the long weapon case and open it. Take the Lancaster Repeater from inside, then check that the weapon name appears when you equip it.

Do not mistake loose ammunition, money, or another container for the main reward. The gun is a fixed pickup in a case, not a random item rolled from the shopkeeper.

You can leave after collecting the repeater and resolving the encounter as you prefer. Taking every other object in the basement is not necessary, and unrelated theft can affect honor or attract additional trouble.

Video: Rhodes basement and Lancaster weapon case — Winston Willamette

5. Leave without adding unnecessary trouble

Put your weapon away when you no longer need it and leave the shop. Keep an eye on witnesses and the wanted state rather than assuming a guide can guarantee a consequence-free robbery in every situation.

The free pickup saves the purchase price, but it does not make every action around the store harmless. Shooting outside, threatening bystanders, or looting unrelated belongings can change how the visit ends.

Once you are safely away, inspect the repeater's condition and ammunition. Treat it like your other long guns: maintain it, carry suitable ammo, and check your horse's stored weapons if it is not immediately on Arthur's back.

If you already own a Lancaster

The basement encounter is still an interesting discovery, but this guide is primarily useful for obtaining the gun early without purchasing it. Check your weapon inventory before expecting a completely new weapon category from the case.

If you have already completed the basement robbery and taken its contents, returning repeatedly is not a reliable method for receiving another fresh reward. The intended opportunity is the original encounter.

If the basement option is unavailable

Confirm that you are in Story Mode, at the Rhodes gunsmith, and have spoken through the barred window. Check for a mission-related weapon restriction or an active wanted situation. Resolve those conditions before trying again. The route depends on the discovery and confrontation sequence; entering the shop and selecting the normal catalog will not expose the free weapon.

Was this helpful?

This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.