How to Complete Now or Never in The Witcher 3: Saving the Mages and the Triss Romance Choice
Now or Never walkthrough: Anisse and Berthold or Olivier, the sewer route and katakan, the docks fight, and the exact replies that keep Triss with Geralt.
Now or NeverArt: CD ProjektSpoiler warning: this guide covers the full quest, its choices and how they play out later.
Now or Never is the last part of Triss Merigold's Novigrad story. It unlocks after A Matter of Life and Death, when a messenger hands Geralt a perfumed letter from Triss. Usually that happens once you have met King Radovid during Redania's Most Wanted. Triss is smuggling the city's last mages out of Novigrad before the witch hunters burn them. Your job is to escort them through the sewers to a ship bound for Kovir.
The quest has two decisions that matter. The first is whether to rescue two missing mages, Anisse and Berthold. Rescue them and Olivier, the Kingfisher innkeeper, is killed while you are away. The second comes on the docks, where you either let Triss sail or ask her to stay. Pick "Stay with me" and then "I love you" in the timed dialogue, having already kissed her during A Matter of Life and Death, and Triss stays. The night ends at the lighthouse.
| At a glance | |
|---|---|
| Starts at | Triss's hideout, northeast of Hierarch Square, Novigrad |
| Requirements | A Matter of Life and Death completed; letter from Triss |
| Missable | Triss romance, Olivier's survival, the mages' escape (before The Isle of Mists) |
| Rewards | XP (500 for the katakan, 300 for the docks fight and more), loot, A Deadly Plot |
| Outcomes | Triss sails to Kovir, or stays with Geralt for the night at the lighthouse |
Step-by-step
- Read the letter and go to Triss. Head to her hideout northeast of Hierarch Square. Witch hunters loiter outside, and you can deal with them now or when you leave together.
- Handle the landlords. Triss's landlords are squeezing her for more money. You can threaten them or stay quiet. If you stay quiet they take her necklace, and if you step in she scolds you. Neither choice changes the outcome.
- Decide on Anisse and Berthold. Most of the mages are already waiting in the Kingfisher's cellar, but these two never arrived. Choose "We should help Anisse and Berthold" to go after them, or "Don't risk everything for two people" to go straight to the inn.
- Rescue path. Follow Triss to their building past the patrols. Upstairs, witch hunters are holding the couple. Attack fast, because they can kill the mages if you hold back. Cast Axii on Berthold to talk him into leaving, then escort both of them back to the Kingfisher. Olivier is dead there, and you have to fight a group of witch hunters inside the inn.
- Go down to the sewers. In the Kingfisher's cellar, Sigi Reuven (Dijkstra) has joined the escape. You scout ahead through the sewers with Triss. Keep her with you, because a locked door on the route only opens when she is there.
- Clear the tunnels. Expect drowners and level 15 mucknixers, so necrophage oil helps. Use Aard on the cracked walls to find side rooms and a hidden library, and burn the rat swarm with Igni.
- Kill the katakan. Just before the exit, a level 14 katakan attacks. It regenerates and turns invisible. Keep Quen up, slow it with Yrden and use vampire oil if you have it. Killing it gives 500 XP.
- Fight on the docks. At the harbor, a crowd of witch hunters blocks the ship. Triss, Dijkstra and his men fight with you, and winning gives 300 XP.
- Say goodbye or ask Triss to stay. A cutscene follows as the mages board. See the next section for the exact replies.
- Talk to Dijkstra. After the scene, Dijkstra hints at removing Radovid. If you have done the quests he needs, this starts A Deadly Plot. Now or Never ends near the Lighthouse signpost on the Novigrad waterfront.
Choices and outcomes
Anisse and Berthold vs. Olivier. You cannot have both. If you rescue the two mages, the delay gets Olivier killed at the Kingfisher. If you go straight to the inn, Olivier survives and Anisse and Berthold are left to the hunters. Olivier is also a Gwent opponent, so play him first if you want his card. If you lose that chance, it can still be looted from a storeroom east of the bar.
The docks: the romance choice. This is the one that changes the story:
| "Stay with me" → "I love you" | Any other reply, or waiting out the timer | |
|---|---|---|
| Requirement | You kissed Triss in the hedge maze during A Matter of Life and Death | – |
| Triss | Stays behind; you spend the night together at the lighthouse | Boards the ship and sails to Kovir with the mages |
| Romance | Triss becomes Geralt's partner | Triss stays a friend for the rest of the game |
| Kaer Morhen | She returns for the battle | She still returns for the battle |
The dialogue is on a timer. Hesitating counts as a refusal, so pick your reply quickly. The hedge-maze kiss is a hard requirement. Without it the romance replies will not work, no matter what you say on the docks.
Yennefer. Choosing Triss here and then romancing Yennefer later does not end well. If you want a clean ending with one of them, commit to that one.
Skipping the quest. If you never help Triss, the mages do not get away and are burned instead. Novigrad's witch hunts carry on either way, so even the good outcome is not a happy one for the city.
Rewards
- 500 XP for the katakan, 200 XP for reaching the harbor, 300 XP for the docks fight, plus XP when the quest ends
- Crowns and crafting loot from the sewer rooms and corpses
- The katakan can drop a Katakan mutagen, but it is not guaranteed
- A Deadly Plot from Dijkstra, if you meet its requirements
Common mistakes
- Skipping the kiss earlier. If you did not kiss Triss during A Matter of Life and Death, her romance is already gone before this quest starts.
- Taking too long on the docks. Letting the timer run out is the same as letting her go.
- Slow fighting in the rescue room. If you hesitate, the witch hunters can kill Anisse and Berthold.
- Leaving Triss behind in the sewers. The locked door will not open without her.
- Waiting too long. Finish Now or Never, and A Deadly Plot if you want it, before you sail to The Isle of Mists. Novigrad quests left open at that point can fail.
FAQ
Can I save Olivier and Anisse and Berthold? No. Rescuing the couple always costs Olivier his life.
Does Triss fight at Kaer Morhen if she sails to Kovir? Yes. Finishing her questline is what counts, and she comes back for the battle whether or not you asked her to stay.
Can I still romance Triss if I said "I love you" without the kiss? No. You need both: the kiss in A Matter of Life and Death and the right replies on the docks.
Is the romance permanent? It carries into the rest of the story. Romancing Yennefer as well leads to an awkward scene and leaves you with neither of them.
Sources
This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.