How to Complete Carnal Sins in The Witcher 3: Who the Killer Is and Every Outcome
Carnal Sins walkthrough: every clue, how to talk Reverend Nathaniel down at Crippled Kate's, who the real Novigrad killer is, and what happens to Priscilla.
Carnal SinsArt: CD ProjektSpoiler warning: this guide names the killer and covers every outcome of the quest.
Carnal Sins is the Novigrad murder mystery that starts at the end of Cabaret, when word arrives that Priscilla has been attacked. Geralt follows a trail of mutilated victims through the hospital, the morgue and several crime scenes, and the investigation seems to point straight at Reverend Nathaniel Pastodi, the fanatical Eternal Fire preacher. He is not the killer. The real murderer is Hubert Rejk, the friendly coroner who helps you all along, and he turns out to be a vampire.
The one moment that decides the outcome is the confrontation with Nathaniel at Crippled Kate's. If you attack him, or pick a hostile line that starts a fight before he explains himself, the investigation ends with the wrong man dead and Hubert walks free. Talk to Nathaniel first, and he gives you the clue that sends you to Hubert's warehouse at the docks. Priscilla survives either way.
| At a glance | |
|---|---|
| Starts at | Novigrad, at the end of Cabaret |
| Suggested level | 16 |
| Key NPCs | Dandelion, Joachim von Gratz, Hubert Rejk, Reverend Nathaniel |
| Missable | Catching the real killer (talk to Nathaniel before fighting) |
| Rewards | 500 XP, Deargdeith silver sword, Katakan mutagen, Assassin's Boots diagram |
| Outcomes | Hubert unmasked and killed, or Hubert escapes after Nathaniel dies |
Step-by-step
- Visit Priscilla at the hospital. After the news breaks in Cabaret, go to Vilmerius Hospital. Dr. Joachim von Gratz is treating Priscilla. Her injuries are serious but she should pull through, and he links the attack to earlier victims killed the same way. He suggests examining the latest body at the morgue.
- Reach the morgue through the sewers. The doctor leads you underground to avoid attention. Expect drowners and a water hag before you climb the ladder into the morgue.
- Examine the dwarf's body. Use Witcher Senses to find the murdered woodcarver and study the wounds. Coroner Hubert Rejk joins you and names Eustace, the man who collected the body. Reverend Nathaniel then barges in and orders you out.
- Investigate the three leads (any order).
- Priscilla's alley: A group of locals locks the gate and attacks. Knock them out, then talk to Whistling Wendy, who first takes you for the killer. Witcher Senses show the attacker escaped over a wall far too high for any normal person to jump.
- The woodcarver's workshop: His brother Gus lets you in. Search the yard, then ask Gus to unlock the workshop and search it too.
- Eustace the corpse collector: He robbed the body. Pay him 200 crowns or use Axii (Delusion level 2 is needed), and he comes clean.
- Return to the coroner. After two leads, a guard reports a new murder and says Hubert wants you. You can finish the third lead first. At the morgue, Hubert "finds" a note on the new body naming the next victim: Patricia Vegelbud.
- Race to the Vegelbud residence. Talk your way past the guard and follow Ingrid Vegelbud upstairs. Her mother is already dead and the killer flees. If you give chase, the house guards mistake you for the murderer and drag you back. Ingrid vouches for you, and the body holds another note naming Sweet Nettie at Crippled Kate's brothel.
- Confront Nathaniel at Crippled Kate's. Go to the top floor. Nathaniel has Nettie tied up and is torturing her with a hot poker. This is the critical scene, covered below. Talk to him calmly and he works out that only the coroner knew where he would be, then points you to a warehouse at the docks.
- Face Hubert at the warehouse. It sits just west of the Novigrad Docks signpost. Hubert admits everything, explains his twisted crusade against the "immoral," and changes into a vampire. The fight cannot be avoided.
- Report to Dandelion. Return to the hospital. Priscilla is recovering, Dandelion thanks Geralt, and the quest ends.
Choices and outcomes
Talk to Nathaniel before you fight. When the scene starts, do not answer his threats in kind. A safe route is "Just like that? No formaldehyde?" followed by "So who left the letter on Patricia's body?" Insults or an early attack start a fight right away.
What to do with Nathaniel afterward. Once he has named the warehouse, you have three options:
| Choice | Result |
|---|---|
| Kill him | 100 XP, Tracker's Trousers, Ard Skellig Aketon diagram, his poker |
| Axii him into leaving | Nettie is spared and Nathaniel walks away |
| Leave him to it | You walk out and Nathaniel carries on with Nettie |
None of these choices block the warehouse fight once you have the lead.
The wrong outcome. If Nathaniel dies before he names the coroner, Geralt treats him as the murderer and the next objective sends you back to Dandelion instead of the docks. You keep Nathaniel's loot but miss the 500 XP and the vampire's gear. Hubert is never caught, and a mocking note later makes clear the real killer slipped away to carry on elsewhere.
Clues that point to Hubert. The game lets you work it out before the reveal. Von Gratz remarks that Hubert has barely aged in decades. The alley shows a jump no human could make. And every note naming the next victim turns up after Hubert has handled the body.
Priscilla's fate. She survives in every version of the quest. The doctor's worry is her singing voice, and by the end she is recovering well and may sing again.
Rewards
- 500 XP for defeating the real killer
- Deargdeith, a silver sword, from Hubert's body
- Katakan mutagen (can drop from Hubert)
- Diagram: Assassin's Boots and a Lesser Svarog Runestone
- 100 XP, Tracker's Trousers and the Ard Skellig Aketon diagram if you kill Nathaniel
- Small XP for getting Eustace to talk
Common mistakes
- Attacking Nathaniel on sight. It looks like a rescue, but it ends the hunt for the real killer.
- Picking a hostile reply in the brothel. A rude answer starts the fight just as surely as drawing your sword.
- Fighting Hubert without Quen or vampire oil. He turns nearly invisible and regenerates quickly, so keep Quen up, coat your silver sword with vampire oil and stay aggressive.
- Threatening Eustace. Intimidation does not work on him. Pay or use Axii instead.
FAQ
Who is the killer in Carnal Sins? Hubert Rejk, the Novigrad coroner. He is a vampire who murders people he considers immoral.
Is Reverend Nathaniel innocent? Of the murders, yes. He is still a cruel fanatic, which is why killing him after he talks costs you nothing.
Can I spare Hubert? No. The fight at the warehouse happens no matter what you say.
Does Priscilla die? No. She survives in every outcome.
Sources
This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.