The Bloody Baron Quest Guide (The Witcher 3): Family Matters Choices and Every Outcome

Every step of the Bloody Baron questline in Velen, from Family Matters to Return to Crookback Bog, and which choices decide the fates of the Baron, Anna and the orphans.

Art: CD Projekt

Spoiler warning: this guide covers the full questline and its outcomes.

Family Matters starts at Crow's Perch in Velen, right after the main quest The Bloody Baron. Phillip Strenger, the Baron, will only tell Geralt what he knows about Ciri if you find his missing wife Anna and daughter Tamara. The search runs through a pellar's cottage, a cursed grave, a fisherman's hut, Oxenfurt and finally Crookback Bog, where it merges with the Ladies of the Wood questline and ends in Return to Crookback Bog.

The single choice that decides the ending is not in Family Matters at all. It is what you do with the spirit under the Whispering Hillock, a side quest you must finish during Ladies of the Wood. Kill it and the Baron and Anna leave together, but the orphans of Crookback Bog are lost. Free it and the orphans are saved, but Anna dies and the Baron hangs himself. The botchling choice changes the route, not the ending.

At a glance
Starts at Crow's Perch, Velen (after The Bloody Baron)
Requirements Ciri's trail in Velen; Ladies of the Wood to finish it
Missable Calming the botchling with Axii, saving the burning stable, Tamara in Oxenfurt
Rewards XP, crowns, Letter of Safe Conduct, Ciri flashbacks
Outcomes Baron leaves with Anna, or Anna dies and the Baron hangs himself
Video: Family Matters full quest guide and endings (by LunarGaming)

Step-by-step

  1. Search the family's rooms. Speak to the Baron on the upper floor of Crow's Perch. In Anna's bedroom (west side), use Witcher Senses on the hole in the wall and the broken candlestick, then follow the scent of a broken bottle to a talisman. In Tamara's room (east side), take the key and incense from the wardrobe, follow the smell to the basement and open the locked door to find a shrine to the Eternal Fire.
  2. Visit the pellar. The Baron recognizes Anna's talisman and points you to the pellar near Blackbough, northwest of Crow's Perch. The Baron's men are waiting there and you can talk them down, use Axii, or fight. The pellar wants his missing goat back first, which starts the side quest A Princess in Distress.
  3. Learn about the botchling. The pellar's ritual reveals that Anna miscarried and that the remains became a botchling. Read the bestiary entry when prompted.
  4. Confront the Baron. Back at Crow's Perch, a stable is on fire. Saving the stable hand and horses is optional. The drunk Baron then starts a fistfight; knock him down and, once he is sober, he admits he beat Anna and buried the child without a rite.
  5. Deal with the botchling. The Baron leads you to the grave. Choose to kill it, or to turn it into a lubberkin (details below).
  6. Follow the trail. The trail runs to a smokehouse, then to dead horses where rotfiends attack, then to the hut of the fisherman Voytek, east of Crow's Perch. Voytek admits he helped the women escape. A monster killed Anna's horse and carried her into the woods, while Tamara went to his brother in Oxenfurt.
  7. Report to the Baron. He hands over a Letter of Safe Conduct and tells the next part of Ciri's tale, which you play as Ciri's Story: The Race.
  8. Find Tamara (optional). She is in a house in northern Oxenfurt; the letter lets you cross the guarded bridge. She refuses to come home, has joined the Church of the Eternal Fire and gives Geralt a cloth doll from her father.
  9. Find Anna. This happens through Hunting a Witch, Wandering in the Dark and Ladies of the Wood. At the Crookback Bog orphanage, the children point you to Johnny, a godling who saw an ashen-haired girl. His voice was stolen; recover it from a sealed bottle in a harpy nest on the cliffs near Downwarren. Johnny then gets Gran, the orphans' caretaker, to contact the Crones, who send you to the ealdorman of Downwarren, which starts The Whispering Hillock. Gran turns out to be Anna.
  10. Tell the Baron. Report that Anna is in the Crones' power. After the flashback Ciri's Story: Out of the Shadows, he travels to Downwarren and Return to Crookback Bog begins.
  11. Return to Crookback Bog. Escort the Baron through the swamp, help the Eternal Fire soldiers at the orphanage, then defeat the fiend. Quen and relict oil help a lot here.

Choices and outcomes

Botchling: kill or lubberkin. To make it a lubberkin, the Baron carries the botchling into the castle and names it while you fend off wraiths. Cast Axii on the botchling after each wave, or it turns hostile and you have to kill it anyway. The lubberkin then guides you along the trail. Killing it means a harder fight and a blood ritual with the pellar, where you keep fires lit against wraiths. Both routes lead to Voytek's hut, and the choice does not change the ending.

Whispering Hillock: kill or free the spirit. This decides everything:

Kill the spirit Free the spirit (after talking to the ealdorman)
Orphans Taken by the Crones and never seen again Rescued; they later appear in a Novigrad orphanage
Downwarren Spared by the spirit Attacked by the spirit; many villagers die, including the merchant
Anna Lives, but her mind is broken Cursed into a hag; dies even if you lift the curse
Baron Takes Anna away to a healer in the mountains Hangs himself at Crow's Perch

The timing exception. If you free the spirit before you ever speak to the ealdorman about it (by finding the hillock early), Downwarren still suffers, but the orphans are not saved and Anna is not cursed. That gives you the Baron's survival ending.

The doll (free-the-spirit path only). After the fiend, find Johnny again, then pick one of the Crones' dolls to break Anna's curse. The right one carries a violet hollyhock bloom, Anna's favorite flower. With it, Anna returns to human form long enough to say goodbye before she dies. Any other doll and she burns to death in front of her family. Either way, the Baron is later found hanged at Crow's Perch, and his men take over the castle.

Tamara. She never returns to Crow's Perch. In the survival ending she lets her parents go, and she stays with the Eternal Fire.

Rewards

  • XP at almost every step, with large XP for finishing Return to Crookback Bog
  • Letter of Safe Conduct (lets you cross into Oxenfurt over the bridge)
  • Crowns from the Baron and, if you saved him, the stable hand
  • Ciri's Story: The Race and Ciri's Story: Out of the Shadows, plus Ciri's trail to Novigrad

Common mistakes

  • Forgetting Axii in the wraith fight. If you do not calm the botchling after each wave, the lubberkin route closes.
  • Freeing the spirit without knowing the timing rule. Talking to the ealdorman first is what triggers Anna's curse and the Baron's death.
  • Fighting the Baron's men at the Crossroads inn. They remember it at the pellar's cottage and the peaceful options shrink.
  • Playing Gwent too late. The Downwarren merchant can die if you free the spirit, so play him early if you want his card.
  • Fighting the fiend without Quen. Its charge and hypnotic gaze punish anyone who stands still.

FAQ

Can the Baron and Anna both survive? Yes. Kill the spirit, or free it before speaking to the ealdorman. The cost is the orphans.

Does killing the botchling ruin the ending? No. It only changes the route to Voytek's hut and makes the fight harder.

Was this helpful?

This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.