How to Complete Reason of State in The Witcher 3: Radovid's Fate, Dijkstra vs Roche and Every Outcome

How to unlock Reason of State, when it becomes missable, how the plot against Radovid plays out, and what siding with Dijkstra or Roche does to the ending.

Reason of StateArt: CD Projekt

Spoiler warning: this guide covers the full questline and its outcomes.

Reason of State is the Act III secondary quest in which Geralt joins Dijkstra, Vernon Roche and Thaler in a plot to kill King Radovid. It does not appear in your journal on its own. Dijkstra offers it during the main quest Blindingly Obvious, after you corner Philippa Eilhart, and only if you have already finished the conspiracy chain: An Eye for an Eye, Redania's Most Wanted and A Deadly Plot. A Deadly Plot itself only opens once Triss's Novigrad quests (A Matter of Life and Death and Now or Never) are done.

The quest is easy to lose. Finish the three prerequisite quests before you start The Isle of Mists, pick the friendly bribe instead of shoving Dijkstra aside in Blindingly Obvious, and complete Reason of State before you start the final main quest, On Thin Ice. The last conversation decides who rules the North, and it also matters for Ciri: siding with Dijkstra rules out the ending where she becomes Empress.

At a glance
Starts at Dijkstra, during the main quest Blindingly Obvious (Act III, Novigrad)
Requirements An Eye for an Eye, Redania's Most Wanted, A Deadly Plot (which needs Triss's Now or Never)
Missable Yes – prerequisites before The Isle of Mists, the quest itself before On Thin Ice
Rewards 25 XP, Assassin of Kings achievement/trophy
Outcomes Radovid dies; then either Dijkstra dies (Roche wins) or Roche, Ves and Thaler die (Dijkstra wins)
Video: Reason of State full walkthrough (by VGFAQ)

Step-by-step

  1. Unlock it in Blindingly Obvious. After you catch Philippa, Dijkstra confronts you and demands her. Do not choose the option that shoves him aside – that permanently closes the plot. Instead, offer him information about Emperor Emhyr's plans in exchange for letting you go. Dijkstra reveals that he wants Radovid dead too, and Philippa can be used as bait.
  2. Go to Dijkstra's warehouse in the Novigrad docks. Knock to get in and head upstairs, where Dijkstra, Roche and Thaler are waiting. They lay out the plan: Geralt tells Radovid he has found Philippa's hiding place and leads him across the bridge to Temple Isle, where the conspirators will strike. Agree to take part.
  3. Take the ring from Philippa. As you leave, Philippa (who listened in as an owl) stops you and hands over Vizimir II's Ring, a keepsake Radovid will recognize as proof that you really found her.
  4. Board Radovid's ship at the docks. His ship is now moored at Novigrad. Speak to the Redanian soldier at the gangplank, then talk to Radovid. Say what he wants to hear about Philippa and show him the ring. He believes you and marches toward the bridge with his men.
  5. Survive the ambush on St. Gregory's Bridge. Radovid turns on Geralt and leaves soldiers to deal with him. Roche's men step in and give you your swords back. Clear the Redanian soldiers and witch hunters, then push across the bridge with Roche, Ves and the Blue Stripes.
  6. Watch the assassination. At the barricade at the end of the road, Philippa blinds Radovid and stabs him, then escapes as an owl. This is the moment the Assassin of Kings achievement unlocks.
  7. Meet the conspirators at the theater. The group regroups in a nearby theater. Thaler reveals that the Temerians want peace talks with Nilfgaard; Dijkstra refuses, announces he will run Redania himself, and his men surround Roche, Ves and Thaler. A timed choice follows (see below). The quest ends after it.

Choices and outcomes

The only choice that changes the world is the last one at the theater. You cannot side with Dijkstra and save Roche at the same time.

Choice Who dies Northern Kingdoms epilogue
Stay out of it (let Dijkstra act) Roche, Ves and Thaler Dijkstra rules Redania and the North wins the war against Nilfgaard. He governs by fear, but industry prospers. Emhyr loses.
Refuse to let him kill them Dijkstra and his men Nilfgaard wins the war. Temeria is restored as a vassal state with a measure of independence under Roche.
Never unlock or never finish the quest Nobody in this quest Radovid survives, Redania defeats Nilfgaard, and Emhyr is overthrown and killed by his own people.

Two other choices can end the plot early. Shoving Dijkstra in Blindingly Obvious means the quest is never offered, and backing out when the conspirators ask you to join closes it as well.

Does Reason of State affect Ciri's ending?

Yes, indirectly. Ciri can only become Empress if Emhyr survives and Nilfgaard wins the war. That requires Radovid to die in this quest and Roche to win at the theater. If Dijkstra takes over, or Radovid lives, Nilfgaard loses, and the Empress ending is no longer available.

Reason of State is not the deciding factor on its own, though. Whether Ciri becomes Empress, a witcher, or does not return depends mostly on how Geralt treats her in the late main quests (the snowball fight, Skjall's grave, the laboratory, letting her talk with the sorceresses alone, and taking her to see Emhyr without accepting payment). The Witcher ending is still possible whichever way the theater choice goes.

Rewards

  • 25 XP for the assassination.
  • The Assassin of Kings achievement/trophy for taking part in killing Radovid.
  • The political outcome in the epilogue, which also decides whether the Empress ending is possible.

Common mistakes

  • Starting The Isle of Mists too early. An Eye for an Eye, Redania's Most Wanted and A Deadly Plot must be finished before it, or Dijkstra never makes the offer.
  • Skipping Triss's Now or Never. A Deadly Plot depends on it, so leaving Triss's storyline unfinished locks the whole chain.
  • Shoving Dijkstra in Blindingly Obvious. The forceful option feels satisfying, but it removes Reason of State for that playthrough.
  • Starting On Thin Ice with the quest still open. The quest fails once the final main quest begins.
  • Missing the timed choice. The theater decision has a timer. Read the options before the scene starts so you do not default to the outcome you did not want.

FAQ

Is Now or Never a Roche quest? No. Now or Never is Triss's quest about getting the mages out of Novigrad. It matters here only because it leads into A Deadly Plot.

Does the bribe in Blindingly Obvious cost anything? No. You only trade information about Emhyr's plans; it is simply the dialogue path that keeps Dijkstra friendly enough to invite you in.

Which choice is best? It depends on the world you want. Back Roche if you want Temeria to survive and keep the Empress ending possible; stand aside if you prefer a free North under Dijkstra.

Was this helpful?

This article was written by AI (Claude) and checked against the sources above. Games are updated regularly, so details may change.